Guest Blogger

Dude, You're a Fag

Filed By Guest Blogger | July 10, 2007 10:00 AM | comments

Filed in: Living, Media, Politics, The Movement
Tags: bloggernista, C.J. Pascoe, faggot, gender roles, language, Michael Crawford, Tim Hardaway

[EDITOR'S NOTE:] The following is a guest post by Michael Crawford. Michael is an African-American LGBT activist and blogger based in D.C. He has worked to advance LGBT civil rights at the national and state levels as a former staff member of the Human Rights Campaign and an organizer of the Millennium March on Washington. He blogs at

That's the slur that UC Berkeley sociologist C.J. Pascoe heard quite often as she researched her new book of the same title on masculinity and sexuality in high school. Boys used the word "fag" not necessarily to describe another boy as having same-sex sexual desires, but the word was thrown at other boys who were considered feminine and not fitting in with rigid notions of what a boy should act like.

Boys participated in a fag discourse to ensure that others saw them as masculine by renouncing any fag-like behavior or same-sex desire. They did this by imitating fags and calling other boys fags. Boys imitated fags by lisping, mincing and pretending to sexually desire men, drawing laughs from male audiences who howled at these imitations.

Its been more than a few years since I have been in high school, but this seems about right. Boys are taught as they grow up a narrow code of masculinity that proscribes acceptable ways for boys and men to act, think and feel. Anything that smacks of "acting like a girl" is considered suspect and a sign of weakness. Pascoe also found that the boys she studied differentiated between "gay" and "fag."

For these boys gay men could still be masculine, whereas a fag could never be masculine. Thus the term "gay" functioned as a generic insult meaning "stupid" or "lame" whereas "fag" invoked a very specific gendered slur, directed at other boys. For these boys a fag was a failed, feminine man who, in all likelihood, was also gay.

Pascoe goes on to describe how this intimidation of boys considered weaker or less masculine becomes a kind of name calling ritual that is as much about denying homosexuality as it is about not appearing feminine. You would think that as boys grow older and become men that they would out grow this social anxiety around proclaiming the masculinity by targeting men and boys that are seen as not "acting like men." And, you would be wrong.

We can see evidence of this in the ongoing national debate around allowing openly gay soldiers to serve in the military, Tim Hardaway's "I hate gays" comments and the recent Snickers commercial in which two men accidently kiss and have to immediately take action that restores their fragile sense of masculinity like ripping out their own chest hair. On a more personal level, notice how some men will not sit next to their male friends in a movie theater or on the subway. They leave a seat between them so as not to appear to be too physically close to other men.

Its been said before that homophobia and sexism are intertwined and Pascoe's study would seem to be more proof that that is the case. By challenging sexism, we challenge homophobia. And, by challenging both we give boys the opportunity to grow into the men they truly are rather than the men they think they should be.

Read an article by Pascoe describing her work here.

Leave a comment

We want to know your opinion on this issue! While arguing about an opinion or idea is encouraged, personal attacks will not be tolerated. Please be respectful of others.

The editorial team will delete a comment that is off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, includes a slur or is soliciting and/or advertising. Repeated violations of the policy will result in revocation of your user account. Please keep in mind that this is our online home; ill-mannered house guests will be shown the door.

I remember when I was a junior in high shool my best friend and I went out after our final exams to lunch and I distinctly remembered he sat down at a very large table that could seat 6 instead of just sitting at a table for 2 people, he also did not sit across from me but rather diagonally to me.. kinda struck me as a little odd.. but I also distinctly remember hearing the word fag used to describe something that was so unbelievably unacceptable in their eyes, while gay was just something stupid. Even after they came out they continued to use those words and told me that it wasnt insulting to me, I was like.. excuse me... from my understanding high school is still the same way...

Jen Jorczak | July 10, 2007 4:22 PM

AMEN! Thanks for posting this, Michael and Bil. Homophobia and sexism are totally intertwined, and by fighting them both, we're not only helping boys/ men but also girls/ women and society as a whole. Here's to a day when we are all allowed to simply be who we are.

This is something that we need to talk about more and more. Even in the LGBT community we are not able to escape rigid gender norms and stereotypes. We see the personal saying things like "straight-acting seeking same" or hear gay men make fun of athletic women.

We are lead to believe that the behaviors traditionally associated with gender are ingrained in our DNA when the are so not.