Steve Ralls

Setting the Pace on Gays in the Military

Filed By Steve Ralls | September 26, 2007 8:58 PM | comments

Filed in: Politics
Tags: Don't Ask Don't Tell, military, peter pace, Servicemembers Legal Defense Network, steve ralls

General Peter Pace, the outgoing Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, has clarified his earlier remarks about gays in the military. Speaking before the Senate Appropriations Committee this afternoon, and prompted by questions from Iowa Senator Tom Harkin, Pace indicated that he might be open to changing the "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" ban on lesbian, gay and bisexual troops.

“Are there wonderful Americans who happen to be homosexual serving in the military? Yes,” Pace said. “. . . we should respect those who want to serve the nation but not through the law of the land, condone activity that, in my upbringing, is counter to God's law.” And then, the kicker: "I would be very willing and able and supportive” to changes to the policy “to continue to allow the homosexual community to contribute to the nation without condoning what I believe to be activity — whether it to be heterosexual or homosexual — that in my upbringing is not right,” he said, indicating support for policies that would treat behavior by all service personnel, regardless of sexual orientation, the same.

His personal feelings about morality notwithstanding (and he seems to finally understand that perhaps personal views aren't the proper ingredients for military policy), the General's remarks are a welcome change of Pace from his comments in March, when he referred to homosexuality as "immoral."

In March of this year, Pace caused a firestorm of controversy by defending the military's ban and offending gay troops. Servicemembers Legal Defense Network condemned Pace's remarks, and called for an apology. The apology wasn't forthcoming today, but the testimony before Congress was a step in the right direction.

SLDN welcomed Pace's testimony today, but clarified that, if he truly believes in equal treatment for every service member, he should be first in line to call for repeal of "Don't Ask, Don't Tell."

“General Pace is right in his assertion that lesbian and gay personnel should be treated equally alongside their heterosexual colleagues,” said Aubrey Sarvis, the group's executive director. “’Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell,’ however, creates a separate set of standards for gay personnel. The law is about status, and not conduct. Policies regulating conduct are already on the books and should be applied without regard to sexual orientation, but simply being lesbian or gay should not be grounds for dismissal from the armed forces.”

Indeed, the ban on open service says that, just by being lesbian or gay, you can be dismissed from military service. The Uniform Code of Military Justice already penalizes conduct, including adultery and other sexual acts, regardless of a service member's sexual orientation. In his statement today, Pace defended those regulations, but made clear that gays do serve in the armed forces, and a change in policy to allow them to continue to do so would be proper. And that's good news.

SLDN, for one, is hoping the General, who retires on Sunday, will remain resolute in his view and become part of the conversation about toppling this ban once and for all.

“We welcome General Pace’s comments today, and hope he will continue to speak out for the equal treatment of every service member, regardless of their sexual orientation,” said Sarvis. “The lesbian and gay community has a long history of service in our military, and that commitment and dedication should be appreciated. SLDN looks forward to continuing this dialogue with General Pace.”

If General Pace elects to be a part of that dialogue, he could be an important ally in the fight to repeal "Don't Ask, Don't Tell." And that would be setting the right pace for changing this unfair and un-American law.

Recent Entries Filed under Politics:

Leave a comment

We want to know your opinion on this issue! While arguing about an opinion or idea is encouraged, personal attacks will not be tolerated. Please be respectful of others.

The editorial team will delete a comment that is off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, includes a slur or is soliciting and/or advertising. Repeated violations of the policy will result in revocation of your user account. Please keep in mind that this is our online home; ill-mannered house guests will be shown the door.

indicating support for policies that would treat behavior by all service personnel, regardless of sexual orientation, the same.

Unless, of course, he means that in the religious right way - both gay and straight people can't have relations or relationships with people of the same sex. See? It's not discrimination anymore!

I'm not as hopeful about this as SLDN seems to be. I'm thinking Pace is just muddying what he said but sticking with his prejudices. Fine, he's retiring, so they don't matter anymore.

I've noticed quite a few other blogs that have taken a negative tone on this issue - for him saying things like "counter to God's law." Unlike Alex though, I agree with Steve, that politically Pace's statements have a deeper meaning than the negatives he attached.

As far as I know, this is the 1st time someone of his stature - while still being on active duty - has admitted that gays and lesbians serve the military with distinction. That's a huge step forward. And for him to also admit that while he has personal issues with homosexuality, it shouldn't be the basis for whether or not a servicemember should keep their job is also huge.

I have a feeling that Steve's going to be out of a job soon. Not to wish bad things on you, Steve! (I'm sure you'll find another great job right away - you're excellent at what you do!) DADT is going to crumble within the next year, I think.

If you talk to the troops in Baghdad, they could care less if Gays and Lesbians are serving.