Sara Whitman

Ben and the mink

Filed By Sara Whitman | January 16, 2008 9:30 AM | comments

Filed in: Living
Tags: child care, fur, gender identity, gender roles, kids, LGBT families

I know the world is going to hell in a hand basket. Citigroup lost billions. Stock market is tanking, oil prices rising, and average Americans who thought they might retire someday are realizing it's a ridiculous, outdated notion.

I know there are bigger fish to fry, like Mitt Romney over pretty much anything that comes out of his mouth. Or Huckabee's connection with various religious extremists. Or McCain's inability to string a sentence together without the clear desire to use a profanity.

Not that I mind that- it actually makes me like him.

But today I realized, I have to do something about my son Ben and the mink coat my mother left me.

He was on his way to pick up his brother's at after school- it's a block away from home and he is old enough to do this "errand" for me. He opened the closet for a coat.

Mom? Can I wear the mink?

I paused a moment- it is an expensive coat. Not that I ever wear it.




Then he paused a moment.

Nah, just kidding.

He looked longingly at the coat in the closet.

Should I just give him the coat? Take it somewhere and have it refashioned into a men's style?

The gender rules he's struggling with right now are so painful. I know he wants the coat. I know he wanted to wear it, just the way it is. It's soft, smells great and is so warm. When he puts it on, he does a little twirl.

He loves it.

(All the PETA members can settle down- these minks have been dead since about 1950. The coat has been refashioned more than once. Let's not make the minks have died in vain.)

On one hand, you don't hand a kid who never hangs anything up, a coat worth a lot of money. In our neighborhood, no one is walking around wearing mink coats. Not adults, not kids- no one.

On the other, for him it's a beautiful thing. It's secretly feminine in his mind. No one knows it's a "girl" thing and he can get away with it. It's like being a lesbian and wearing men's boxer shorts.

Not that I know anything at all about that.

I want to help him find ways to express himself that won't get him teased, taunted or humiliated. He's riding high on being "popular" and it's a position that he's worked hard to achieve. It also makes him tense about every moment and every choice around his presentation in the world.

It's not earth shattering, to be certain. It's only a coat. Ben is 12 and he's been making these choices since he was two years old. He's struggled with what is expected of him as a boy, what his heart tells him and the reality of him having to make a choice to express it. Our society accepts masculine girls (as long as they grow out of it) but not feminine boys. Go to any preschool and count the girls in jeans and sneakers.

Count the boys wearing dresses and tights.

I want him to grab the mink and wear it. And my pearls, which he's eyed at different times. I want him to say fuck it to all the rules and be who he wants to be, wear the clothes he wants and do his little twirl in public. It doesn't make him gay, it doesn't make him unmanly, it just makes him someone with a highly developed sense of style and fashion.

And I know what would happen if he did.

Leave a comment

We want to know your opinion on this issue! While arguing about an opinion or idea is encouraged, personal attacks will not be tolerated. Please be respectful of others.

The editorial team will delete a comment that is off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, includes a slur or is soliciting and/or advertising. Repeated violations of the policy will result in revocation of your user account. Please keep in mind that this is our online home; ill-mannered house guests will be shown the door.

Thank you for this article! I used to "get caught" wearing my mother's night gown, which I loved. When asked by my much-suffering mother why I wore the night gown, I would say: I love the feel of the fabric on my skin! Sensuality is the first thing children experience! Touch is immediatley interpreted, whereas we must learn momma voice and daddy's laugh. (Or Daddy's voice and daddy's laugh, or whatever!) Your son loving that coat, and you loving your son for loving that coat, is what this world needs more of! Whatever he ends up being sexuality wise matters not one whit - he loves that coat and wants to ear it, and you would actually pay to have it made into a more "manly" style to help him be able to indulge in that sensuality! Good for you!

The thing that is interesting about that story is that I know that I myself was having the reverse issue as a twelve year old. I am still young enough to understand what that felt like and how I struggled with it.

Maybe being female made me more sensitive to the issue, but sometimes I am not sure that's true. But I do know that my heart fell when I read that entry. Limbo, no matter what the issue is, is not a fun place to be.

Just a thought...

I'd rather Ben grew up knowing it was okay to wear women's clothing and be comfortable with his gender identity than to think it was okay to slaughter a hundred little caged and abused animals to make a coat.

His gender identity doesn't hurt anyone. That coat took lives to make.

I'll get off my PETA soapbox now.

PETA MAN! Did I not say the minks have been dead for a LONG TIME?

long long time. dead dead dead.

and it's not okay to wear women's clothing while you are in middle school. it's not. his gender identity, at any age, can get him physically hurt.

but the minks are dead.


I didn't buy it. My mother did.

she's dead, too.

Well, you have to admit - most people don't run around wearing live minks... Just sayin'... :)

As for the serious question though - I agree about wearing women's clothing in school, but if it's at home? Is that something you allow?