Austen Crowder

Videogame Censorship, LGBT, and Birdo (Part III)

Filed By Austen Crowder | December 21, 2009 9:30 AM | comments

Filed in: Entertainment, Transgender & Intersex
Tags: birdo, censorship, doki doki panic, LGBT, nes, NES10 chip, nintendo, seal of quality, super mario brothers 2, transgender, video games

This is part three of Austen's three-part series on videogame censorship. Part one dealt with the videogame crash, Nintendo of America's early "Seal of Quality" validation process, and the birth of Birdo as a Mario character. Part two dealt with the Genesis, Super Nintendo, and Japanese-American cultural differences' impact on game content. Part three deals with the changing videogame market, Birdo's stealth return, and the gamer press's treatment of the pink wonder.

The 16-bit era came and the 16-bit era left. As gamers, we moved on to the Next Big Thing in MP8Scene.jpggaming: 3d graphics. The next generation of console games were coming to market, and with them came a new segment of players. Videogames were no longer seen exclusively as kid's toys, as many of the people who grew up playing in the arcades and in their childhood bedrooms had now become game-playing adults, complete with adult budgets and adult spending power.

Families began playing games together. A new genre of games - the party game - was invented to service this newer, more casual market. Gaming companies discovered that women enjoyed videogames, even when they weren't covered in pink glitter and about domestic chores. The videogame console moved from the teen boy's bedroom to the family living room, and development practices needed to change to match the new market.

With the groundwork set, we can dig into Birdo's resurgence as a character. While it's far from a perfectly inclusive story, her reintroduction to Mario games does make her the first successful transgender character in videogame history.

The Marioization of sports and party games

Nintendo's new console, the Nintendo 64, was made to be a family console. It had four controller ports - revolutionary at the time - and featured a nigh indestructible cartridge system that stood in contrast to the delicate CD media used by its competitors. It's no surprise that Nintendo's internal development teams catered their games to a family audience, both male and female, and designed games with fun multiplayer experiences in mind. This was, however, a unique concept in the world of videogames at the time, and they needed strong brand recognition to sell the concept to weary gamers.

The answer was Mario. Seems anymore you can find a Mario game for every genre: party games, microgames, soccer, basketball, tennis, golf, kart racing... you name it, there's probably a Mario game for it. The Mario universe already had recognizable characters to farm for sports games requiring many characters; add to this the fact that Mario is one of the most recognized faces in marketing history and it would be stupid not to use Mario to sell casual games to families.

However, a tiny change needed to be made to the way character lineups were made: namely, guys weren't the only people at the gaming party anymore. Almost every Mario character now has an opposite-gender counterpart of some sort. Peach has Mario, Daisy has Luigi, Toadette has Toad. This pattern even holds true for Yoshi, who needed his own female counterpart for this new crop of Mario-themed games.

Enter Birdo.

Mario Tennis - Birdo returns after a retcon

Mario Tennis is the first game which featured Birdo as a playable character. A few things about her design are interesting to note:mario-party-7-yoshi-w-birdo.jpg

  • Her slot on the roster indicates that she is to Yoshi's what Peach is to Mario: a partner.
  • She wears a diamond ring on her left hand, suggesting an engagement to Yoshi. This is never specifically stated, but not specifically denied.
  • She is exactly that: she. Not "wanting to be," not "trying to be," not "indeterminate." Just she.

In resurging as a character in the Nintendo universe, Birdo's history was retroactively changed to maintain continuity. This retccon erased her status as a transgender person. To put it another way, Birdo appears in most sports titles in complete stealth. This is unsurprising, considering Nintendo's chokehold on potentially objectionable content. A trans character would be considered unsettling for family-based gamers; however, Birdo's image is memorable, and few people actually remember her male status, let alone read the manual to Super Mario Brothers 2 - that is, if they got a copy that still had the information in it.

Birdo continued to be a run-of-the-mill girl until her status was resurrected, at least historically, in future titles.

Nintendo owns up, then plays potty plots

Super Smash Brothers Brawl had a trophy for Birdo that specifically stated she was of "indeterminate gender." This was the first time in 20 years that Birdo's trans status was even officially hinted at. It should be noted that these trophies are hard to find, let alone collect, and that few casual gamers would have ever seen this specific screen. There is a good chance that those who did see it would already have known the trivia about Birdo's gender status.

However, the Japanese-exclusive game "Captain Rainbow" goes even further, painting Birdo as a transgender woman involved in - you guessed it! - imprisonment over potty politics.

In the game, Birdo is wrongly imprisoned for using the female bathroom, as the robot jailer did not believe her when she insists she is a girl. She gets quite upset about this, and asks Nick to go to her Cute Home and find something that will prove she is not lying. Nick finds a mysterious object under Birdo's pillow, and while it is never revealed exactly what the object is, it serves its purpose and Birdo is released. Birdo develops a crush on Nick, and calls him her "boyfriend". Nick accompanies her in her walks near her Cute Home, and she helps him carry a fallen Star to the altar on the top of Mimin Island. If Nick lets Birdo's wish be granted, she flies into the sky with the Star and disappears.

And, in the "video or it didn't happen" category...

There was a brief period in which "Captain Rainbow" was in line for regionalization and a US release. It's too bad, too: to my knowledge, this scene is the first time in videogame history where a conflict revolved around a trans-specific issue.

Looking forward, we still have a long way to go before characters like Birdo can step out of obscurity and be a part of the gaming world. By and large, the gaming population is still homophobic, transphobic, and misogynistic, and are unwilling to take on the roles of characters that aren't at least straight. The pervasiveness of this issue is so strong that companies are taking action to create safe spaces on their networks, however misguided their action may be. (As an example, Microsoft bans players who either use "gay" in their name, or reference their sexual orientation in their profile - for their own safety and comfort, of course!)

However, with companies such as Bioware creating games that allow players to choose same-sex relationships, and the growing evidence showing that people are willing to engage in cross-gender roleplay in gaming, maybe we're heading in the right direction after all.

If this kind of discussion interests you, be sure to check out the Border House Blog. Their work on the subject is always fascinating! Also, my friend over at Vorpal Bunny Ranch is definately worth checking out.

Leave a comment

We want to know your opinion on this issue! While arguing about an opinion or idea is encouraged, personal attacks will not be tolerated. Please be respectful of others.

The editorial team will delete a comment that is off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, includes a slur or is soliciting and/or advertising. Repeated violations of the policy will result in revocation of your user account. Please keep in mind that this is our online home; ill-mannered house guests will be shown the door.

Fascinating backstory on Birdo. I loved the video. Any idea what the characters are saying?

Not a clue. o.o However, your question does remind me of an internet meme on the subject. (Yes, I'm that girl.)

Interesting series of posts! I seem to remember a bit of that from the manuals on the NES, but never knew that she'd been removed and then re-added.

Of course, I wasn't ever more than a casual gamer.

Actually, it's a mario RPG. It happened in the days before the Sqare Enix merger. It's considered one of the better Mario games of the times, though a sequel will never be made. Square broke off with Sony after the Sony-backed SNES CD project fell through.

Square-Enix later went on to make Kingdom Hearts, a Disney-Final Fantasy mashup.

Don't forget Kingdom Hearts II which is, hands down, the ultimate dream come true for slash fans. There were a couple of blatant male/male pairings in that game. To the point where even my nitwit of a brother couldn't even try to deny it.

Penny Sautereau-Fife | April 26, 2010 2:40 AM

Actuallu the Paper Mario series ARE the sequels to Mario RPG. Square obviously had no involvement but they're RPG's starring Mario, and eventually there was Superstar Saga on the Gameboy Advance which continued the Mario RPG line.

Thanks for this series! It filled in some of the bits of history I didn't know about. I had no idea about Birdo's stint in Captain Rainbow.

Certain sects of the industry itself are surprisingly trans-friendly. Did you know the first Sims game was dedicated to Dani Bunten Berry? (She was the creator of the cult-hit M.U.L.E., and was one of the earliest pioneers in network gaming. And yeah, trans.)

I had heard about Dani -- in fact, I have a couple-paragraph bit on Dani, including the fact that Will Wright dedicated "The Sims" to her memory. I decided to focus on Birdo for this article, since PC gaming opened up a wholly different can o' worms as far as LGBT inclusion was concerned. I plan on coming back to the PC side in a later article.

rapid butterfly | December 22, 2009 8:06 AM

I really enjoy your posts, Austen. I am an avid gamer to be sure, never cared for Nintendo games much (sacrilege, perhaps, but still), but I have to give that franchise more credit now. :-)

Thanks. :) To be honest, I've kinda fallen off the Nintendo bandwagon as well; I sold my Wii once I realized that it was a magnet for shovelware and casual titles, and have become a total sucker for Xbox's achievements. Birdo's story was definitely worth telling, however.

Doesn't she prefer we use the name "Birdetta"? :)

Excellent series, just read all three in a row and quite enjoyed them. I'd seen references to Birdo before, but never seen the story so neatly intertwined with the evolution of video games.

I'm also a die-hard gamer. :) I'm out, trans, and my guild mostly knows about it and accepts me. In fact, I met my current girlfriend there!

I look forward to more articles in this vein! I'd love to see someone take on the role of pre-MMO text based RPGS (MUSHes, MOOs, MUCKs, etc) on the formation of online community amongst GLBT people in the 90's :)