Guest Blogger

The Myth That LGBT Youth of Color Can't Be Supported

Filed By Guest Blogger | March 08, 2011 10:30 AM | comments

Filed in: Living
Tags: Caitlin Ryan, coming out of the closet, Family Acceptance Project, Kyle Bella, teen suicide

Editors' Note: Guest blogger Kyle Bella currently resides in Brooklyn, NY where he is an undergraduate studying through Goddard College's low residency program. He is working on his senior thesis project titled, "Queer: Self. Selves. Selvedges." and writes articles for Colorlines Magazine on a freelance basis.

What do you do when your daughter decides to come out to you unexpectedly at 18? For DeAnna Green, a single African-American mother living in the San Francisco kyle-bella.jpgneighborhood known as Bayview-Hunter's Point, this was what happened. At 18, her daughter Rosetta, now 22, introduced what Green describes as her "girlfriend girlfriend" and came out as a lesbian. Green didn't know what to do or say, remembering moments where she was gripped by confusion and doubt.

As she said, "I had to take a moment to breathe. She had always dressed in a very girly girl way, with dresses and make-up, and now she was telling me about her girlfriend and wanting to wear boxers instead."

Though Green never felt Rosetta's sexuality was a phase, she kept hoping that she would continue wearing the same clothes she used to and everything would be unchanged. She actively told her daughter to be discreet about her sexuality, commenting at one point that she shouldn't march in the San Francisco Pride Parade because she could be on television and "give Grandma a heart attack." And her faith, as an active church-going Baptist, put into question her thoughts on her daughter's sexuality as a sinful act.

But she began warming up to Rosetta's sexuality over time. Slowly she made less of an effort to ask her to wear traditionally feminine clothes. (Green now buys her boxers on a regular basis.) And she came to actively accept her daughter, even if she didn't agree with it from her religious teachings. The change, Green said, came in large part through the help of the Family Acceptance Project, a community-based research and policy initiative in California that's developing the idea that family acceptance of LGBT youth is a proven way to combat challenges like depression and suicide attempts, both of which disproportionately plague queer youth.

The Family Acceptance Project was started in 2002 by Caitlin Ryan, a clinical social worker by trade who has worked with LGBT youth for almost 35 years, and Rafael D├Čaz, a social worker and developmental psychologist who previously taught Ethnic Studies at San Francisco State University.

In the initial phase of the project, researchers conducted a series of interviews, in both English and Spanish, with queer youth and their families from diverse ethnic and religious backgrounds. Ryan stresses that they sought youth from across California and not just within urban communities. Immigrant youth from coastal communities were interviewed along with those who lived in San Francisco suburbs. They aimed to generate a wide range of data on specific actions families take in support or rejection of their child's sexual orientation and gender identity.

With over 8,000 pages of interview transcriptions, researchers were able to show over 100 different specific actions that parents or guardians have taken toward the acceptance--or rejection--of their child.

While it is easy to think about physical abuse, kicking kids of homes and name-calling, the Family Acceptance Project showed that things like "excluding LGBT youth from family events," "blocking youth's access to LGBT friends," or even choosing not to openly discuss sexuality or gender identity were just as detrimental to a child's overall mental health and well-being. Conversely, the study demonstrated, for the first time in any study on LGBT youth, behaviors that improve a youth's well being. These can be as simple as openly "talking with the youth about his or her LGBT identity" and as complex as working to make religious congregations supportive of them. Given the central role religious organizations play in many families of color, researchers were conscious of the ways in which race, religion, sexuality and gender identity can combine in a youth's life.

Ryan says that since she came into the project as a clinician, she could not conceive of it as anything other than "research with impact." So in collaboration with San Francisco General Hospital, the Family Acceptance Project offers free family counseling in English, Spanish and Cantonese, providing information to families struggling to accept their queer youth's sexuality or gender identity. The idea is to offer more than crisis intervention; the counseling is designed as a long-term program to support families as the concerns over accepting or rejecting identity shift.

Among the things the project discovered is a profound lack of broad, communal support for LGBT youth and their families in communities of color. Green's Bayview neighborhood is located in southeastern San Francisco and is nearly 60 percent African American. "Gay and lesbian people are not thought to be in this neighborhood," said Green. "They are all supposed to be in the Castro."

This idea reflects a number of important points. The first is that especially in urban neighborhoods where there are large percentages of people of color, there are often few community resources available to LGBT young people. And that makes family support all the more crucial.

However, it also makes things more difficult for even parents and families who want to be supportive, because there are so few resources to help them figure out how to do so. Parents may love their children regardless of sexual and gender identity, but be unaware of how their actions are affecting their kids. Green and her daughter Rosetta offer an ideal example. Green wasn't aware that her early reluctance to embrace Rosetta's sexuality put her daughter at a nine times greater risk of committing suicide, and that actively accepting sexual orientation significantly decreases that risk. Given this year's rash of LGBT youth suicides, this statistic couldn't be more compelling.

"I can't understand why my religion makes being gay the worst sin on Earth," Green says now. "We are all God's children. If you don't have accepting words for your child, you will make them feel inadequate."

The Family Acceptance Project realizes these stakes and is working with families across geographic regions to, in Caitlin Ryan's words, dispel the "big myth that LGBT youth of color can't be supported."

As Green bluntly sums up, "We have got to accept our children no matter what."

(Crossposted at Colorlines Magazine)

Recent Entries Filed under Living:

Leave a comment

We want to know your opinion on this issue! While arguing about an opinion or idea is encouraged, personal attacks will not be tolerated. Please be respectful of others.

The editorial team will delete a comment that is off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, includes a slur or is soliciting and/or advertising. Repeated violations of the policy will result in revocation of your user account. Please keep in mind that this is our online home; ill-mannered house guests will be shown the door.

Welcome to your first guest post on Bilerico, Kyle. You picked a great topic to start out with! The Family Acceptance Project is one of the most worthwhile programs out there right now.

I enjoyed reading your post, Kyle. And I agree with Bill, you selected a great topic! Access to proper sexual medical care, queer friendly counseling services, discussion-oriented support groups, and safe spaces in school all create significant barriers in this community.

However, we cannot discuss such an issue without addressing how systematic racism and homophobia, as well as the white mainstream gay movement perpeuate the depressed state of these communities, making it difficult for the proper support to be distributed to vulnerable young queer people of color.

Focusing on assimilationist perspectives such as gay marriage, DADT and hate crime legislation exacerbates the very problems you addressed in your piece by continuing to grant privilege to the already priveleged, and emotional and physical poverty to the already impoverished in our society, i.e queer people of color. And to topple that with the prevalent racism, and blunt homophobia and transphobia in our country obviously places enormous pressure on queer people of color, and their families.

Although it is important to look at this topic at a micro level, it is left incomplete without also considering the macro implications, as well.

Anthony Carter | March 8, 2011 3:31 PM


Great post. I am very familiar with how the things that are institutionalized (racism, classism, homphobia)can leave us confused , alone and scared. I am thrilled that there is an organization dedicated to not only the initial well being of our youth but ongoing and evolving support.

Thanks for highlighting the Family Acceptance Project. I have read some of their materials, and I believe their work is so important in starting to establish data on the mental health effects of family attitudes toward queer kids. And based on that data, they are able to make a point in their educational materials that I have not seen discussed in the same way elsewhere, and that I believe has tremendous practical importance: accepting a child's queer identity does not have to be an all-or-nothing leap in order to be helpful. Even if the parent is significantly conflicted herself, refraining from some rejecting behaviors, and exhibiting even one or a few accepting behaviors,( and the research enumerates lots of specific behaviors) is powerfully statistically correlated with better mental health outcomes for the child.

we need to make sure to take an intersectional approach to the topics we discuss here. thank you for bringing this post