Dan O'Neill

Take Action: Dan Choi Arrested in Moscow

Filed By Dan O'Neill | May 28, 2011 5:30 PM | comments

Filed in: Action Alerts, Living, The Movement
Tags: civil disobedience, Dan Choi, Hillary Rodham Clinton, LGBT rights, Moscow

Dan Choi was arrested by Russian authorities earlier today along with several dozen other LGBT-rights activists who clashed with both Moscow police and religious/neo-Nazi opponents after attempting to proceed with a peaceful Pride celebration that inevitably morphed into yet another violent protest. These crackdowns against LGBT people have become a trend in Moscow over the past several years, and events earlier today were the culmination of what has already been a very contentious few days within the Russian capital.

MoscowDanChoiArrestedChoi has reported that he is okay, despite having undergone what appears to be a far more harrowing and aggressive arrest than he has previously experienced during acts of civil disobedience in the US. He has since been released; however, he mentioned that the Russian citizens who were arrested with him would be detained overnight. Choi remains outside the police station in a show of solidarity with his fellow activists.

Pam Spaulding has been actively covering this story, providing regular updates and a live Twitter feed from Dan Choi. Also, for those interested, UK Gay News hosts the Moscow Pride Blog, providing a play-by-play of ongoing developments.

Earlier this spring, LGBT activists were more confident that today would mark the first legally sanctioned Pride parade in Moscow, after multiple attempts over the last several years were thwarted by the homophobic and corrupt former mayor of Moscow, Yury Luzhkov. Luzhkov had been Moscow's mayor since 1992, and was sacked last September by Russian President Dmitry Medvedev. Activists were hopeful the absence of Luzhkov would increase the likelihood of them obtaining their permit. I, along with other friends more familiar with Russian affairs, spoke to Choi shortly before his planned trip, expressing some concern, given rising levels of violence and intimidation by authorities and anti-gay groups. However, Dan seemed optimistic that it would be better this time around.

During last year's attempt at organizing Moscow Pride, the Russian authorities broke up a group of gay protesters, lead by Russian LGBT activist Nikolay Alekseyev, after Luzhkov refused to give a permit for a parade and ordered security services to clamp down on everyone in the "unlawful" assembly. Alekseyev eventually took his case before the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg that, in a symbolic moment for the Russian LGBT rights movement, unanimously ruled that the Russian Federation had violated three articles in the European Convention for illegally banning previous Moscow Pride assemblies.

However, earlier this month, Moscow officials again rejected an application for a Pride parade, in direct violation of the Strasbourg ruling, by indicating it would pose a significant risk to public disorder. It seems Russian authorities are content to play this annual game in order to discriminate against its LGBT citizens.

DanChoiMoscowPoliceTruckOn Thursday, Alekseyev and Choi joined other activists on a live, nationally televised interview/debate with Russia 1, the nation's premier, state-owned television channel. Activists, including Alekseyev, attempted to make their case, debating with a major anti-LGBT member of the Russian Duma (parliament), Alexander Hinstein, and other heads of Russian hate groups. Exasperated from the overtly biased and outright offensive behavior of the debate moderator, Vladimir Solovyov, and other anti-LGBT groups present, Alekseyev stormed off the set, followed by other LGBT activists.

Although the interview was aired in Russia's eastern provinces thousands of miles from Moscow, it was reportedly replaced by another, less volatile activist's interview in the capital later that evening.

Another major element of concern for activists has been the opposition from neo-Nazis and other anti-LGBT groups usually donned in black vests, reported to have been waiting to violently clash with gay-activists at Moscow's City Hall. Alekseyev indicated, he "would not be surprised [if this were] a provocation from the authorities to justify their illegal ban on the basis that the security cannot be guaranteed." It is reported that Moscow police have also detained counter-demonstrators after they initiated clashes with the gay-activists.

City officials said they had received dozens of petitions from these religious and social groups asking them not to permit the parade on the grounds that it contradicts traditional Russian morality. However, one can't help but wonder how much of this violent opposition was informally sanctioned by the government officials, as opposed to stemming entirely from isolated, independent efforts by these anti-LGBT groups. These hate groups pose as a convenient cover for the local government's homophobic inaction and unwillingness to defend peaceful demonstrators.

MoscowPrideFlag.jpgMeanwhile, back in the US there are reports that the telephone switchboard at the Russian Embassy in DC has been swamped over the past 24 hours with calls of support for Moscow Pride and the activists.

I feel this volatile situation is certainly escalating and has the potential to send shock waves throughout Russia; but other friends more familiar with Russian politics feel that the Russian state's stranglehold on the media and control of the narrative around LGBT rights will likely suppress these attempts at progress. Alekseyev is reported to have said on Thursday, prior to his televised appearance, "The next 48 hours will shape the future of Moscow Pride and LGBT community in Russia in general - and I am not joking."

We'll have to see how this story unfolds and how the international community responds; lest we risk repeating this now annual event of brutality towards LGBT people by the Russian government and social/religious hate groups, alike.

Choi has written an open letter to Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton, which he has agreed to personally deliver, with all of your signatures, to the State Department upon his return to Washington. Presently, the United States government has said nothing about the events unfolding in Russia. We can make a difference here, with your help.

Sign Dan Choi's open letter to Secretary Clinton urging her to speak out against the violence in Moscow at AmericaBlog.

In the meantime, my thoughts and admiration are with Dan Choi and the other brave Russian citizens standing up for their civil rights in the face of such terrible risk of violence.

Leave a comment

We want to know your opinion on this issue! While arguing about an opinion or idea is encouraged, personal attacks will not be tolerated. Please be respectful of others.

The editorial team will delete a comment that is off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, includes a slur or is soliciting and/or advertising. Repeated violations of the policy will result in revocation of your user account. Please keep in mind that this is our online home; ill-mannered house guests will be shown the door.

bigolpoofter | May 28, 2011 6:37 PM

Fuck the switchboard! Let's swamp the Russian Embassy with protestors this weekend, even if much of DC is at the beach!

Justus Eisfeld Justus Eisfeld | May 29, 2011 10:07 AM

Thanks for this update. One side of the story, however is missing, and that is the story of other Russian LGBT activists. Many groups in Russia are actually opposing the very direct, public and militant approach that the Moscow Gay Pride group is taking. They feel that this direct approach only polarizes the debate in Russia, but does not actually offer the possibility to reach potential allies. Other groups in Russia prefer to focus on reaching (potential) allies and building relationships through debates and cultural events. Importing foreign activists for public arrest and pictures of bloody noses may not be the best way to win the hearts and minds of those Russians who are allies or could become allies.

Jay Kallio | May 29, 2011 10:50 PM

We here in NYC should be picketing the Russian Consulate, at 9 East 91 St, and demanding they give a permit and police PROTECTION for LGBTQ Pride events.

Nothing has ever changed in human rights and social justice until people went into the streets and put their lives on the line to win their rights.

I agree, Justus. Imagine if HRC tried to hold a rally in some rural area without consulting the local community and used any negative publicity to generate a new fundraising drive. Queers who consider themselves activists need to stop the knee-jerk "everybody who opposes us is a bigot" reaction, especially regarding our international brothers and sisters. And I'm quite sick of the State Department using queerbashing in other countries to create the illusion of support for queer rights and lives. I suspect that if Obama can illegally make war on Libya or if we can pressure other countries to abandon support for the Kyoto Protocols, then certainly Hillary can do more than "express concern" for human rights abuses in Honduras, Moscow, Uganda, or anywhere. How can Obama and Hillary help queers around the world? MAKE US LEGAL AND EQUAL IN THE US NOW!

Read this post from the Petrelis Files.

Note from Bil: Lonnie, I removed the text of Michael Petrelis's actual post from this comment. Reprinting a whole article like that is copyright violation. Not that I think Michael would raise a big fuss, but we hold the policy so we don't get sued when other folks think it's okay to do the same with an AP article or one of the papers represented by Righthaven (the rightwing group suing liberal bloggers for using too much of an article on the site or readers leaving the content in the comments section of the blogs). I replaced the text with a link to the article.

Bill Perdue Bill Perdue | May 30, 2011 1:44 AM

There are people in this country who "are actually opposing the very direct, public and militant approach..."

We call them Democrats, Republicans, HRC etc. But we never, ever call them activists.


Comments like this one is why I ♥ Bill Purdue.

Some of the comments here suggest that this march was not a good idea because it wasn't blessed by the local "good" gay group. Frankly, I think that it is the right of anyone to have a meeting or a march. The fact that local homophobes don't like it is not a reason to oppose the march. Sometimes, you need to confront homophobia and transphobia. I understand, however, that the local "good" gay group needs the approval of the authorities, and they're afraid they'll get punished by the authorities because of the others. That would be a shame.

Bill Perdue Bill Perdue | May 30, 2011 12:39 PM

I agree with Jillian.