Guest Blogger

Porterville, CA to Rescind LGBT Pride Measure Tonight?

Filed By Guest Blogger | July 16, 2013 1:30 PM | comments

Filed in: Fundie Watch
Tags: California, gay marriage, legislative bullying, local government, marriage equality, Porterville, Pride, Prop 8, Prop. 8, same-sex marriage

Editor's Note: Guest blogger Barry Caplan is coordinator of Porterville Equality and Fairness for All (PEFA), a coalition of local LGBT supportive groups, and local chapters of national organizations. To keep up to date, please click here and like PEFA on Facebook.

California entered the hearts and minds of the nation in the past few weeks, with the mid-June Supreme Court ruling that put the final nail in the coffin of Proposition 8's ban on same-sex marriage. Pride celebrations across the state and across the nation have exulted this victory for all of June.

But not all is well in California.

PortervilleMemeJuly162013.pngAllow me introduce you to Porterville, California -- my small Central Valley city of 55,000 -- where the elected officials have waged a five-year battle against the LGBT community and have three more anti-LGBT items on the agenda for tonight's meeting. It sounds impossible, but let me tell you how we got to this point.

In 2008, the Porterville City Council was the only city council in all of California to pass a resolution in favor of Proposition 8. It passed the measure, authored by then first-term councilman Brian Ward, in a unanimous vote.

No local LGBT organization existed at that time, but when the resolution was published in the local paper, the city council was served notice that it couldn't attack LGBT people with impunity anymore. A handful of local LGBT citizens and allies attended the very next meeting, and the effort to have pro-LGBT representation at city council meetings has continued and grown ever since.

Over the ensuing eleven months we attended every public meeting that the council scheduled. We also spoke out during the public comments period, taking a stand against the resolution and educating the public. When then-Mayor Cameron Hamilton was replaced by Pete McCracken in the summer of 2009, the new mayor instituted new rules to limit the amount of time we could speak.

Hamilton soon took advantage and offered a new anti-LGBT resolution, this time opposing State Senator Mark Leno's bill which would have allowed legal same-sex marriages legally performed out of state full recognition in California. A dramatic 90-minute public hearing followed, during which a parade of of people in support of the measure prayed, preached fire and brimstone and eternal damnation on the council and the city. When the vote came, however, our public education efforts paid off: we prevailed in a 3-2 vote, surprising not just Ward and Hamilton -- the only two members to vote for the measure -- but also the city at large.

One of the anti-LGBT councilmembers soon moved out of town, but was replaced by someone equally hostile. Another was voted out of office at the earliest opportunity.

In the ensuing four years since that 2009 vote, a kind of political truce took hold: the city council did not try to address any LGBT issues, and we monitored them to make sure there were no negative attempts.

In the meantime something wonderful happened: the LGBT community, steadily growing in visibility and willing to be seen and heard, started using its energy to improve the City. We became active in other civic matters, inside and outside of City Hall. We began to volunteer for a variety of charities and public service organizations.

Fast-forward four years, to early June 2013. Porterville resident Brock Neeley approached now-Mayor Virginia Gurrola with the idea of a first-ever LGBT Pride Month proclamation. Neely's idea was for the proclamation to honor the LGBT community's four years of dedication to bettering Porterville. Mayor Gurrola agreed to issue it.

Immediately after the Pride Month proclamation was placed on the agenda, the other four members -- still including Ward, Hamilton and McCracken -- objected. Their objections were strong enough, in fact, that they broke protocol: when city council resolutions are introduced, the councilmembers customarily all sign it and then come down to shake the honorees' hands.

PortervilleMayorGurrolaSharesProclamation600413.jpgBut not this time. Only Mayor Gurrola had the courage to sign the LGBT Pride Month proclamation, and she alone came down and shook the hands of the four men and women who received the honor on behalf of Porterville's LGBT community.

Let that sink in for a moment: four elected officials would not sign their name to a proclamation that commended the volunteer efforts of gay people, nor would they be seen in public shaking the hands of gay people.

An impromptu public hearing followed which left the Mayor in tears after attendees wished harm to her and the city.

Another very long and contentious open speaking period occurred on June 18 as procedural efforts to rescind and replace the proclamation moved forward, as did an effort to change the longstanding process by which proclamations are approved.

A large crowd on both sides is expected again tonight. By now the cast of characters opposed to the Proclamation are clear. Regular speakers on the anti-LGBT side have included:

- a Westboro Baptist Church cohort with authentic "God Hates Fags" signs (WBC denies knowing him, but we have video that says otherwise)

- a local Nazi apologist who spews racist, homophobic and anti-Semitic rants on the internet

- local business and "Christian" leaders who are always quick to claim that polygamy, incest, bestiality and pedophilia will result if all loving couples can have a civil marriage.

Only Mayor Gurrola has disavowed these extremists. Even if the rest of council has come to their anti-LGBT views for different reasons, the truth is that they are now politically aligned with the people above.

Tonight, members of the Porterville City Council will have a clear choice to make: they can vote for equality and move Porterville into the modern era, or they can align with anti-LGBT extremists and allow the town to remain hostile and unwelcoming to LGBT people.


Leave a comment

We want to know your opinion on this issue! While arguing about an opinion or idea is encouraged, personal attacks will not be tolerated. Please be respectful of others.

The editorial team will delete a comment that is off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, includes a slur or is soliciting and/or advertising. Repeated violations of the policy will result in revocation of your user account. Please keep in mind that this is our online home; ill-mannered house guests will be shown the door.